One question I have is, is the William A Lavelle in the role of Guildenstern of a March 10, 1884 production of Hamlet at Haverly's in NY with Edwin Booth in the title role the same William of the "Wilds of the West" 3 years later in 1887?
This is the problem I have in not being able to find him in other sources such as directories, outside of an 1873 directory in Chicago.
Any ideas about how to figure this out? I'm trying to find an instance where a William A Lavelle is in Chicago and NY simultaneously, but haven't come across this yet.