Genealogy Wise

The Genealogy & Family History Social Network

When one has firsthand knowledge of an event, such as the death of a relative, and the only documentation one has is a newspaper obit, what surety level does one assign to the event? I have been using "3. Almost certain conclusion", but I am not comfortable with that. Your thoughts?

Views: 75

Replies are closed for this discussion.

Replies to This Discussion

If the obituary agrees with your firsthand knowledge and you agree it is accurate, I would be comfortable with a surety level of 3. On the other hand if the obituary is the only knowledge you have, I would rate it lower. My mother's, father's, and brother's obituaries published in our small town newspaper were full of inaccuracies. Since I had first hand knowledge (I was there), those obituaries will have low surety levels if I use them at all. In all three of those cases I supplied information to the Funeral Director who sent it to the paper. Somewhere things went wrong. Barb
I agree with Barbara's assessment. I've added hundreds of obits to my Legacy database and have noticed numerous inaccuracies in many of them. However, first-hand knowledge allows me in most cases to sort out the good from the bad. The same can be said for information on death certificates. Often the informant's information is inaccurate when compared with first-hand knowledge.
First hand knowledge ( you were there at the funeral) - I would say 100% - you know it is a fact! Just my opinion - ut I know of nothing that could be more sure.

Keith
Seems to me if you have first hand knowledge of the event, there's really not anything that is much better. I think you are right. I agree with the others.
So, is the surety level about the accuracy of all information in the source or is it whether it relates to the relative?
In the described situation, I would assign two sources to the event (death):

1. "Personal Knowledge of [me]" with a surety level appropriate to the level of confidence that I have in my first-hand knowledge of that event (probably a 4);

2. the obit, with a surety level based on how accurate the obituary is (of course, my assessment of that accuracy would be based on my knowledge, so I suppose that's circular logic, but it works for me.)

RSS

Members

© 2024   Created by IIGSExecDirector.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service